Friday, April 10, 2009

GEOGRAPHY CLUB Under Fire Again: My Reponse

So my book Geography Club is under fire by book banners yet again, this time in West Bend, Wisconsin. I wrote an essay response for the Milwaukee paper (the nearby daily), but they chose not to print it. But -- you luck folks -- here it is!

It's hard not to take it personally when someone wants to ban your book.

A group of folks in West Bend have made a varying list of demands regarding
my 2003 teen novel, Geography Club: ban it, put a warning label on it, put it somewhere where teenagers can't get it without permission from their parents, or buy books to "balance" it that show what a horrible, immoral "lifestyle" being gay is.

My book has been out for more than six years, sold tens of thousands of copies, received almost unanimously good reviews, won many honors, and is currently being adapted for the movies.

But truthfully, this is not the first time that some people, often with the backing of national conservative Christian activist groups, have tried to ban the book. Libraries are, of course, about open access to information, and there's really not much more fundamental in America than the right to decide for ourselves what we want to read, and what we want our kids to read.

These activists, on the other hand, want to make the decision for the rest of us. So
they make ridiculous assertions, based on the inclusion of a few swear words in
my book, that it's "pornographic."

Oftentimes their demands sound reasonable. Why not put a sticker on a book that some find offensive? But who decides what's "offensive"? Trust me: there is something in every book that someone somewhere doesn't like. Should a twelve-year-old go into the woods alone with a loaded gun? One does in Where the Red Fern Grows. Should kids always show respect to their parents? They don't in Roald Dahl's Matilda.

Why not put "controversial" books in a special section where the books require parental approval to be checked out? Again, who decides what's "controversial"? And for the record, the real point of this strategy isn't to give parents "choice"; it's to drive down circulations, which is what libraries use to determine their collections, making it so they can't justify buying similar books.

Why not buy "anti-gay" books to satisfy people who feel that homosexuality is a horrible, immoral lifestyle? Every librarian I've ever met tries hard to satisfy the needs of their own community and to have a broad, diverse collection. But while I know it's an article of faith among some that homosexuality is a "choice" and that the "media" are burying the "truth" about how horrible the "gay lifestyle" is, these are not the books that respected authors and educators are writing; few of these books exist and even fewer are published and reviewed by respected sources because they're mostly based on falsehoods and misrepresentations, like books about how the Holocaust never happened.

Once you are the subject of these book debates a number of times, as I have been, you quickly realize something: some people really dislike, and even fear, gay people and their inclusion in our communities.

Ironically, anti-gay prejudice is part of the reason why I wrote my book in the first place.

I wish everyone who thinks my books are not "appropriate" for teenagers could read my mail for one single week -- the avalanche of touching emails I receive from lonely or harassed gay and lesbian teens and their friends, so grateful to see gay characters portrayed accurately and with dignity, not merely stereotypes or the punchline of jokes.

And let it be noted: plenty of parents want their kids reading my books. I frequently hear from parents who've read my books with their teens. In one of the most flattering emails I've ever received, one teenager said, "I gave my parents your book and said, 'Please read this. This is how I feel.'"

So I think my critics really miss the point.

In every teen book I've ever written, gay-themed or not, there is a moment when the main character has to choose between moving beyond his or her own little bubble -- doing what would make him or her momentarily happy or comfortable -- and putting those selfish prejudices and concerns aside, and committing to a larger cause, a greater good. In my mind, that's the choice every teen confronts, again and again, because it's the difference between a child and an adult.

Do books with that message have a place in libraries and in the hands of teenagers and their parents?

Absolutely. In fact, there might be a few adults in West Bend who could benefit from reading books like that too.

Brent Hartinger


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Go you! Stand up against censorship!

9:05 AM  
Anonymous Joyce Mary said...

I noted that the West Bend paper carried your response, and was glad to see it there. I just read Geography Club over the weekend -- YA lit is not my field, sorry, has nothing to do with you -- and I would consider it a fine contribution to a public library collection. I think it is important to look at IF challenges in public libraries in the light of government control of access to information. Hence the firing of the West Bend library board members for supporting retention of the challenged materials. Next we can expect the city council to threaten cuts to the library budget. This is why we need to develop policies ensuring the independence of public libraries. Thanks for your work keeping this visible. Joyce M. Latham, Ph.D.

6:46 AM  
Blogger SafeLibraries® said...

Brent Hartinger is quoted on this matter in the following:

"Wisconsin Library Challenge Heats Up," by Debra Lau Whalen, School Library Journal, 7 May 2009.

By the way, Joyce Mary, the library board members were not fired as you stated, and the action taken was for a different reason than you stated. They simply were not reappointed, part of the normal means for local control. I now see you are the same Dr. Latham to whom I wrote the following: "W-M Library School Misleads West Bend Citizens. And now you are here misleading more people. Nice.

6:30 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

More power to ya' Brent! I hope your novel "Geography Club" is soon made into a movie. Keep us posted on GC movie news k? I think it would personally, kick-ass!!

I love you all of you books!!

9:30 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

直航機票自由行三久太陽能三久太陽能太陽能熱水器別墅外觀設計環保袋別墅外觀設計室內裝修電波拉皮hand dryer電波拉皮雷射溶脂肉毒桿菌工商登記公司登記投審會會計師會計師事務所系統家具台中漆彈場漆彈團體服美國月子中心團體服團體服團體服T恤宜蘭民宿關鍵字廣告seo網路廣告網路行銷seo網站設計seo線上客服seo網頁設計seo網頁設計公司網路行銷網路行銷桃園室內設計室內設計作品室內裝潢裝潢室內設計室內設計公司

4:06 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


4:07 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home